Strictly Pizza

Discover delicious New York-style pizza at Strictly Pizza, located at 4400 Boston Post Rd, Pelham. Enjoy handcrafted pies, garlic knots, flavorful slices, and classic favorites like chicken parm and bacon. Call +1 914-738-0024 for takeout or dine-in today!

Welcome to Strictly Pizza

Signature Dining Experience

Strictly Pizza
Strictly Pizza
Strictly Pizza
Strictly Pizza

Strictly Pizza welcomes everyone with open arms and a mouth-watering array of pizza offerings. Located at 4400 Boston Post Rd, Pelham, NY, this pizza haven radiates warmth and community spirit. Each bite tells a story rooted in Italian tradition and local flavors, ensuring that your appetite finds exactly what it craves. Garlic knots melt in your mouth, while the famous grandma slice tantalizes with its perfect blend of sauces and toppings.

Ensuring a welcoming atmosphere, Strictly Pizza has become a staple in the neighborhood where friends gather and families share meals. So, whether it’s a quick slice or a full pie, this bustling eatery invites you to indulge in iconic pizza styles and hearty portions that leave a lasting impression.

Location & Contact

Address

4400 Boston Post Rd, Pelham, NY 10803, United States

Phone

+1 914-738-0024

Social Media

About

Strictly Pizza
Strictly Pizza
Strictly Pizza
Strictly Pizza

Strictly Pizza began as a simple vision: to offer the taste of authentic Italian pizza to the Pelham community. The heart of this establishment resides in its culinary roots, reflecting Italian heritage through every dish. Each pizza is crafted with high-quality ingredients, ensuring a delicious experience that balances tradition with a modern twist.

Stepping inside, the lively atmosphere buzzes with excitement as locals grab a slice or two. The decor throws a nod to traditional pizzerias while embodying a contemporary flair—think family photos and checkered tablecloths. The walls tell tales of cherished memories and friendly gatherings over numerous shared meals. The combination of friendly staff and frequent community events only cements its position as a beloved spot.

The menu caters to a variety of tastes. From the creamy cheese pie to the spicy array of buffalo pies, everyone finds something to love. Vegetarian options like the margherita pie delight those seeking a healthier option while still savoring rich flavors. Popular menu additions, such as chicken parm rolls or sausage and peppers rolls, ensure that everyone leaves satisfied. And let’s not forget the garlic knots—always a fan-favorite and perfect for sharing—or enjoying by oneself.

For those with a sweet tooth, dessert options round out the dining experience. The welcoming vibe and accommodating service make dining here a true treat. Each bite invites patrons back for more, creating a sense of belonging within the local community. This isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a gathering place, where every meal comes with a side of connection.

Work Hours

  • Sunday11 AM-10 PM
  • Monday11 AM-10 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-10 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-10 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-10 PM
  • Friday11 AM-10 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-10 PM

Strictly Pizza stands out with its range of hearty offerings and inviting ambiance. The extensive menu includes everything from cheese pies to specialty options such as buffalo and margherita varieties. The customers rave about the signature garlic knots, which pair perfectly with their homemade marinara sauce. The all-day rolls and calzones provide ideal choices for those seeking a quick bite or a full meal.

For a family night or a late dinner, expect a cozy vibe filled with laughter and chatter, especially on busier nights. Conveniently, the restaurant accommodates dine-in or takeout, perfect for those who prefer to enjoy these flavors at home. With a peak time on Friday evenings reaching full capacity, planning a visit during off-peak hours can enhance the dining experience.

Strictly Pizza

Strictly Pizza’s exterior exudes charm with its welcoming façade, inviting both locals and newcomers alike. The classic signage draws attention from afar, creating a recognizable landmark on Boston Post Rd. Outdoor seating offers a picturesque view for those who enjoy al fresco dining while enjoying warm evenings in Pelham. The lively vibe spills out onto the street, making it a go-to for families and friends gathering for a friendly meal.

Inside, the casual yet cozy atmosphere embraces diners, ensuring a comfortable and relaxed dining experience. The cheerful chatter and aromas of fresh pizza wafting through the air add to the energetic ambiance, making it hard not to smile when entering.

Customer Reviews

If you're looking for your new favorite pizza spot, let me put you on to Strictly Pizza This was my first time visiting and wow... they completely stole my heart. Every single pizza I tried was absolutely amazing -- fresh, flavorful, and perfectly made. But the real star of the show? The upside down pie. It was hands down my favorite! The balance of sauce, cheese, and crust was just chef's kiss. And can we talk about that exotic garlic sauce?! It has my whole heart It's so unique, so flavorful, and unlike anything I've tasted before. I would honestly go back just for that sauce alone. On top of the incredible food, the vibes were immaculate. The atmosphere felt welcoming and fun, and the people were so friendly and helpful. You can really tell they care about their customers and their craft. Highly, highly recommended -- this is a must-visit Love, Farhin

F
Farhin G.

I stumbled upon this lovely little pizza place by complete chance when I took a detour off the parkway, and I am very glad that I did! The atmosphere in this modern chic pizzeria is adorable and inviting, as was the service (and fast enough to get me back on the road quickly!) As for the pizza, the BBQ Chicken and Plain slices were fantastic and tasted incredibly fresh (not always a given at by-the-slice places), with thin and crispy crust and plenty of sauce to go around. Whether you are a Pelham local or happen to be passing by on the Hutch, this place is definitely worth the pit stop!

S
Sean M.

There have been so many great new pizza spots opening up in the area and this place is no exception! I ordered a well done Sicilian pie and it was cooked to perfection and tasted absolutely delicious. The pie had nice amount of cheese and the sauce tasted amazing! Lastly I am happy to see that they use a proper box for their Sicilian pie like not all pizzerias do and that they use the little pizza tables as well. This makes a huge difference especially for delivery so it is very much appreciated! Can't wait to try more from here, keep up the awesome work guys!

M
Mike

This was a nice upscale vibe of a pizza shop. Different slices available. Staff were all really nice. I had a regular slice and a margarita also. Close to the shopping area, highway and right over the bridge is the Bronx.

F
Franny B.

Excellent pizza slices! Went just after 9pm, with less then an hour from the shop closing and slices were still hot and fresh. I had the grandma slice and grandma slice with pesto, the flavors were crisp and on point. The staff also gave me free zeppoles while I waited, which was really nice. The restaurant was clean, less then 10 minute wait for food, and they accept credit card which not all slice shops will. And best of all you're on the Hutch headed home in 1 minute...5 stars

J
J K.

What a great find on Boston Road! Ultra-clean, modern, and the staff were super friendly. We grabbed a plain pizza slice and a chicken parm slice, plus garlic knots with hot marinara, and everything tasted fantastic. The vibe is cozy and welcoming, and we're already planning our next visit to try more options. Highly recommend Strickly Pizza if you're in the Bronx.

R
Rosie C.